The Hay Group Study
Health Care Plan Design and
Cost Trends--1988 through 1997
APPENDIX A
Typical Plan Design 1988 and 1997
Typical Plan Designs
Dollars have not been updated for inflation.
| Feature |
1988
(FFS - 92% of plans) |
1997
(FFS- 20% of plans) |
| Deductible |
Individual: $100 Family: $300 |
Individual: $200 Family: $400 |
| Hospitalization |
Maximum Number of Days: Unlimited Inpatient Hospital Coinsurance: 80%
Inpatient Surgery Coinsurance: 80%
General Coinsurance: 80% |
Maximum Number of Days: Unlimited Inpatient Hospital Coinsurance: 80%
Inpatient Surgery Coinsurance: 80%
General Coinsurance: 80% |
| Physician Visits |
Inpatient Physician Visits Coinsurance: 80% Outpatient Physician Visits Coinsurance: 80% |
Inpatient Physician Visits Coinsurance: 80% Outpatient Physician Visits Coinsurance: 80% |
| Outpatient x-ray & lab |
Coinsurance: 80% Subject to General Deductible |
Coinsurance: 80% Subject to General Deductible |
| Prescription Drugs |
Covered Co-pay: $2 per prescription (brand name or generic) |
Covered Co-pay: $5 generic; $10 brand name
Purchase of generic is NOT required
Voluntary mail order pharmacy service available |
| Out-of-pocket Limits |
Individual: $1,000 Family: $3,000 |
Individual: $1,000 Family: $3,000 |
| Vision Care |
Not Covered |
Not Covered |
| Dental Care |
Separate Dental Deductible: $50/person Deductible waived for preventive care
Preventive Care Coinsurance: 100%
Basic Restorative Care Coinsurance: 80%
Major Restorative Care Coinsurance: 50%
Maximum Annual Dental Benefit: $1,000
Orthodontia Coinsurance: 50%
Max. Lifetime Orthodontia Benefit: $1,000 |
Separate Dental Deductible: $50/person Deductible waived for preventive care
Preventive Care Coinsurance: 100%
Basic Restorative Care Coinsurance: 80%
Major Restorative Care Coinsurance: 50%
Maximum Annual Dental Benefit: $1,000
Orthodontia Coinsurance: 50%
Max. Lifetime Orthodontia Benefit: $1,000 |
Under PPO and POS plans, the coinsurance for
out of network services is reduced by 20%.
| Feature |
1997
(PPO - 34% of plans) |
1997
(POS- 22% of plans) |
| Deductible |
In network: $200 Ind/$400 Family Out of network: $400 Ind/ $800 Family |
In network: None Out of network: $150 Ind/$300 Family |
| Hospitalization |
Maximum Number of Days: Unlimited Inpatient Hospital and Surgery Coinsurance:
90% In network |
Maximum Number of Days: Unlimited Inpatient Hospital and Surgery Coinsurance:
100% In network |
| Physician Visits |
Inpatient Physician Visits: 90% In network Outpatient Physician Visits: 100% In network |
Inpatient Physician Visits: 100% In network Outpatient Physician Visits: 100% In network |
| Outpatient x-ray & lab |
Coinsurance: 100% In network Subject to General Deductible |
Coinsurance: 100% In network Subject to general deductible (out of network) |
| Prescription Drugs |
Covered Copay: $5 generic/$10 brand name
Purchase of Generic is NOT required
Voluntary mail order pharmacy service available |
Covered Copay: $5 generic/$10 brand name
Purchase of Generic is NOT required
Voluntary mail order pharmacy service available |
| Out-of-pocket Limits |
In network: $1,000 Ind/ $2,000 Family Out of network: $2,000 Ind/ $4,000 Family |
In network: $1,000 Ind/ $2,000 Family Out of network: $2,000 Ind/ $4,000 Family |
| Vision Care |
Not Covered |
Not Covered |
| Dental Care |
Separate Dental Deductible: $50/person Deductible waived for preventive care
Preventive Care Coinsurance: 100%
Basic Restorative Care Coinsurance: 80%
Major Restorative Care Coinsurance: 50%
Maximum Annual Dental Benefit: $1,000
Orthodontia Coinsurance: 50%
Max. Lifetime Orthodontia Benefit: $1,000 |
Separate Dental Deductible: $50/person Deductible waived for preventive care
Preventive Care Coinsurance: 100%
Basic Restorative Care Coinsurance: 80%
Major Restorative Care Coinsurance: 50%
Maximum Annual Dental Benefit: $1,000
Orthodontia Coinsurance: 50%
Max. Lifetime Orthodontia Benefit: $1,000 |
| Feature |
1997 (HMO - 24% of plans) |
| Deductible |
None |
| Hospitalization |
Unlimited No Copay |
| Physician Visits |
Inpatient Physician Visits: 100% Outpatient Physician Visits: $10 Copayment |
| Outpatient x-ray & lab |
No Copay |
| Emergency Room |
$25 Copay |
| Prescription Drugs |
Covered Copay: $5 Generic/$10 Brand
Generic Required if available
Mail order pharmacy service is available |
| Out-of-pocket Limits |
None |
| Vision Care |
Not Covered |
| Dental Care |
Separate Dental Deductible: $50/person Deductible waived for preventive care
Preventive Care Coinsurance: 100%
Basic Restorative Care Coinsurance: 80%
Major Restorative Care Coinsurance: 50%
Maximum Annual Dental Benefit: $1,000
Orthodontia Coinsurance: 50%
Max. Lifetime Orthodontia Benefit: $1,000 |
######
NAPHS
900 17th Street, NW, Suite 420
Washington, DC 20006-2507
Phone: 202/393-6700
Fax: 202/783-6041
E-mail: naphs@naphs.org |